Credit Repair Review

Article

Subprime Credit Card Fees: How They Eat Into Your Credit Limit

Subprime card fees can swallow a big share of a small credit limit. Here is the 25% first-year cap, what counts toward it, and what to check before you apply.

6 min read

Subprime Credit Card Fees: How They Eat Into Your Credit Limit

Federal rules limit the fees a card issuer can require you to pay in the first year to 25 percent of your credit limit. On a subprime card with a small limit, that still leaves room for fees that take a large bite out of the credit you can actually use.

This matters if you are rebuilding credit and a low-limit card is the one that approved you. Below, we cover the rule, what counts toward it, a real enforcement case and what to check before you apply.

The 25% first-year cap: what the rule says

The rule sits in Regulation Z, at 12 CFR 1026.52. It says the total fees a consumer is required to pay on a credit card account during the first year after account opening must not exceed 25 percent of the credit limit in effect when the account is opened. An account counts as open no earlier than the date you can first use it for transactions.

A worked example

The math is simple, so you can run it on any offer you're considering:

  • A $300 limit allows up to $75 in counted fees in year one.
  • A $500 limit allows up to $125.
  • A $1,000 limit allows up to $250.

The cap is a ceiling, not a target. A card can charge less, and one with no required fees is under it by definition.

What the cap does not cover

The rule does not apply to late payment fees, over-the-limit fees and returned-payment fees. It also leaves out fees you are not required to pay, such as an optional service you chose to add. So a card can sit under the 25 percent line and still cost you more if you pay late.

What counts toward the cap

The CFPB's official commentary on the rule, published with § 1026.52, fills in three details that matter on small-limit cards.

Fees billed to the card and fees paid another way

The limit applies to fees the issuer charges to the account. It also applies to fees the issuer requires you to pay through other means. An issuer cannot dodge the cap by asking you to send a separate payment for a fee it would otherwise bill to the card.

Security deposits

The commentary says a security deposit that is charged to a credit card account is a fee for purposes of the cap. A deposit that is not charged to the account is not subject to the 25 percent limit, and you may be asked for pledged funds at opening that exceed 25 percent of the limit, as long as those funds are not taken from the account. If you are weighing a secured card, our piece on (/secured-credit-card-no-deposit-what-it-means/) covers how the deposit and the limit relate.

If the issuer lowers your limit

The cap is tied to the limit in effect at opening, but a cut in year one changes the math. The commentary says the issuer must waive or remove fees charged to the account that exceed 25 percent of the reduced limit, or credit the account, no later than the end of the billing cycle after the one in which the limit was cut. Its example: a $1,000 limit with $250 in fees, cut to $600. The issuer has to remove $100.

A real case: Continental Finance, 2015

On February 4, 2015, the CFPB (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/archive/newsroom/cfpb-orders-subprime-credit-card-company-to-refund-2-7-million-for-charging-illegal-credit-card-fees/) to about 98,000 consumers and pay a $250,000 civil penalty. It is an older case, but it shows how fast small limits fill up with fees.

Here are the numbers the CFPB reported:

  • The typical credit limit was $300.
  • The company charged a $75 upfront maintenance and setup fee. That is exactly 25 percent of $300.
  • It also charged a $4.95 monthly paper statement fee, up to an additional $49.50 in the first year.
  • Combined, the fees reached as much as 42 percent of the $300 limit in the first year.

The CFPB said this violated the CARD Act's fee cap and the Truth in Lending Act. It also said the company misrepresented the paper statement fee and whether security deposits were FDIC insured.

The lesson isn't that every subprime card breaks the rule. It's that a fee you can switch off, like a paper statement, can still count when it is required, and that the cap is enforced.

How fees shrink the credit you can use

A credit limit is the maximum balance you can carry. When a fee posts to the account, it becomes part of your balance. A fee isn't a purchase, but it uses up room just the same.

Take a $300 card with $75 in fees posted in the first months. You have $225 of room left before you buy anything. If you then charge $100, you are at $175 of a $300 limit, or about 58 percent. Credit scoring models look at how much of your limit you are using, so a fee-loaded small limit can leave you near the line without much spending. Treat that as arithmetic, not a prediction. The effect on your score depends on your whole file.

The same logic runs in reverse. If a card needs a deposit to open, a deposit not charged to the account leaves your limit intact, while a deposit charged to the account is treated as a fee under the cap.

What to check before you apply

Before you accept a subprime offer, run through this list:

  1. Find the fee table. Look for setup, annual, monthly and paper statement fees. Add up what is required in year one.
  2. Compare the total with 25 percent of the limit. If the offered limit is $300, required fees above $75 in year one are a red flag.
  3. Ask how each fee is collected. Charged to the card, or paid separately? The cap reaches both.
  4. Check the deposit terms on secured cards. Capital One's (https://www.capitalone.com/learn-grow/money-management/how-to-get-a-credit-card-with-no-deposit) says minimum deposits of $49, $99 or $200 can open a secured account with a credit line of at least $200, and that a larger deposit can raise the starting line.
  5. Plan the next step. Once you have a card, you can (/credit-limit-increase-soft-pull-without-hard-inquiry/) so fees take up a smaller share. If a fee-heavy card is not worth it, see (/alternatives-to-self-lender-credit-builder-2026/).

If you think an issuer charged more than the cap allows, you can submit a complaint to the CFPB and ask the issuer in writing to remove the excess.

Bottom line

Required first-year fees on a credit card cannot exceed 25 percent of the opening limit, but late, over-the-limit and returned-payment fees sit outside that cap, and a small limit makes any fee feel large. Do the arithmetic on the fee table before you apply, and keep every statement in year one.

If your credit is the reason you are stuck with these offers, you can (/#top-companies) for professional help with inaccurate items on your reports.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a limit on how much a credit card can charge in fees the first year?

Yes. Federal rules say the total fees you are required to pay in the first year must not exceed 25 percent of the credit limit in effect when the account opens. Late, over-the-limit and returned-payment fees are not counted.

On a $300 limit, what is the most in required fees the first year?

25 percent of $300 is $75, so required first-year fees counted under the rule cannot go above $75.

Do late fees count toward the 25 percent cap?

No. The rule text excludes late payment, over-the-limit and returned-payment fees, as well as fees you are not required to pay.

Does a security deposit count as a fee?

A deposit charged to the card account counts as a fee. A deposit that is not charged to the account is outside the 25 percent limit.

What happens if the issuer cuts my limit in the first year?

The issuer must remove or credit fees above 25 percent of the reduced limit by the end of the billing cycle after the cut.

Editor's Pick · #1 in 2026

The Credit People

Free Consultation

Start
See 2026's top picks